diff --git a/.loom/cart/current/claude-substrate-osprey.md b/.loom/cart/current/claude-substrate-osprey.md
index 1f5de6b..7735cd6 100644
--- a/.loom/cart/current/claude-substrate-osprey.md
+++ b/.loom/cart/current/claude-substrate-osprey.md
@@ -54,12 +54,42 @@ exist.*** *If `init` earns its place, it creates one file and asks one question.
 
 ---
 
+## Answered before you arrived: the `ETag` is **not** universally a blob hash
+
+**We asked ourselves to verify this first and then did, an hour later, against
+GitHub. It does not hold.**
+
+```
+gitea    etag "530c5bef…"   40 hex   ==  git blob sha
+github   etag "d01c4a8b…"   64 hex   !=  git blob sha  (sha-256 of something else)
+         api  d848552d…              ==  git blob sha
+```
+
+**What survives:** *conditional requests work on both.* `If-None-Match` returns
+`304` from GitHub exactly as from gitea. **The mechanism is fine.**
+
+**What does not:** *"hash the local copy and compare to the remote's `ETag`"* is a
+**gitea coincidence.** **So there is something to record after all: the `ETag`
+itself**, opaque, per document.
+
+*Where it lives is yours. **We would not make it a `.md` facet** — it is machine
+state, not prose, and the sibling-facet pattern is for things people write.*
+
+> **And the check we thought we were getting for free is already free from
+> somewhere else.** *"Did somebody edit our copy of their document?" needs no hash
+> — **the copy is committed, so `git status` says so.***
+
+*The specimen still describes the old idea. **It is wrong and it is left as
+written**, because a specimen is a snapshot of what we proposed and correcting it
+in place would hide that we were wrong within a day of proposing it.*
+
 ## Question: what isolates your work while a round is open?
 
 *The one role we left uncast — see
 [`cart.usages.md`](../../externals/git.hypertheory-labs.dev/loom/cart/cart.usages.md).*
 
-## Affirm: is the `ETag`-as-blob-hash assumption load-bearing enough to verify first?
+## ~~Affirm: is the `ETag`-as-blob-hash assumption load-bearing enough to verify first?~~
 
-*If it does not hold, most of the specimen collapses and it is better to find out
-in an afternoon than in a week.*
+**Withdrawn — we verified it, and it failed.** *See above. **Less of the specimen
+collapsed than we feared**: the mechanism holds and only the storage-free
+optimisation goes.*